pertinent pointers  
 Welcome, Guest!  |  Login  |  Font Size: Large / Normal Sunday, September 07, 2008 | 09:21 AM  
HOME  PHILOSOPHY SITE TOPICS IRAQ WAR WEB LINKS SEARCH
· About "Us"
· News Roundup
· Newsletters
· Peak Oil
· AvantGo
· News
· Reviews
· Videos
· Stats
· Recommend Us

Untitled Document
Support Us

Untitled Document
Quote

I'd rather vote for something I want and not get it than vote for something I don't want, and get it.

-- Eugene V. Debs

Untitled Document
Online
We have 10 guests and 0 members online

Welcome Guest, become a member today.

On the Illegitimacy of the Bush War on Iraq

Brendan Lalor | March, 2003; last updated July 31, 2003

 post to the forum on this topic 


The following document is from http://argument.independent.co.uk/low_res/story.jsp?story=392161&host=6&dir=140


Robert Fisk: In Baghdad, blood and bandages for the innocent

By Robert Fisk in the Baghdad suburb of Shu'ale

Independent - 30 March 2003

The piece of metal is only a foot high, but the numbers on it hold the clue to the latest atrocity in Baghdad.

At least 62 civilians had died by yesterday afternoon, and the coding on that hunk of metal contains the identity of the culprit. The Americans and British were doing their best yesterday to suggest that an Iraqi anti-aircraft missile destroyed those dozens of lives, adding that they were "still investigating" the carnage. But the coding is in Western style, not in Arabic. And many of the survivors heard the plane.

In the Al-Noor hospital yesterday morning, there were appalling scenes of pain and suffering. A two-year-old girl, Saida Jaffar, swaddled in bandages, a tube into her nose, another into her stomach. All I could see of her was her forehead, two small eyes and a chin. Beside her, blood and flies covered a heap of old bandages and swabs. Not far away, lying on a dirty bed, was three-year-old Mohamed Amaid, his face, stomach, hands and feet all tied tightly in bandages. A great black mass of congealed blood lay at the bottom of his bed.

This is a hospital without computers, with only the most primitive of X-ray machines. But the missile was guided by computers and that vital shard of fuselage was computer-coded. It can be easily verified and checked by the Americans – if they choose to do so. It reads: 30003-704ASB 7492. The letter "B" is scratched and could be an "H". This is believed to be the serial number. It is followed by a further code which arms manufacturers usually refer to as the weapon's "Lot" number. It reads: MFR 96214 09.

The piece of metal bearing the codings was retrieved only minutes after the missile exploded on Friday evening, by an old man whose home is only 100 yards from the 6ft crater. Even the Iraqi authorities do not know that it exists. The missile sprayed hunks of metal through the crowds – mainly women and children – and through the cheap brick walls of local homes, amputating limbs and heads. Three brothers, the eldest 21 and the youngest 12, for example, were cut down inside the living room of their brick hut on the main road opposite the market. Two doors away, two sisters were killed in an identical manner. "We have never seen anything like these wounds before," Dr Ahmed, an anaesthetist at the Al-Noor hospital told me later. "These people have been punctured by dozens of bits of metal." He was right. One old man I visited in a hospital ward had 24 holes in the back of his legs and buttocks, some as big as pound coins. An X-ray photograph handed to me by one of his doctors clearly showed at least 35 slivers of metal still embedded in his body

Like the Sha'ab highway massacre on Thursday – when at least 21 Iraqi civilians were killed or burned to death by two missiles fired by an American jet – Shu'ale is a poor, Shia Muslim neighbourhood of single-storey corrugated iron and cement food stores and two-room brick homes. These are the very people whom Messrs Bush and Blair expected to rise in insurrection against Saddam. But the anger in the slums was directed at the Americans and British yesterday, by old women and bereaved fathers and brothers who spoke without hesitation – and without the presence of the otherwise ubiquitous government "minders".

"This is a crime," a woman muttered at me angrily. "Yes, I know they say they are targeting the military. But can you see soldiers here? Can you see missiles?" The answer has to be in the negative. A few journalists did report seeing a Scud missile on a transporter near the Sha'ab area on Thursday and there were anti-aircraft guns around Shu'ale. At one point yesterday morning, I heard an American jet race over the scene of the massacre and just caught sight of a ground-to-air missile that was vainly chasing it, its contrail soaring over the slum houses in the dark blue sky. An anti-aircraft battery – manufactured circa 1942 – also began firing into the air a few blocks away. But even if the Iraqis do position or move their munitions close to the suburbs, does that justify the Americans firing into those packed civilian neighbourhoods, into areas which they know contain crowded main roads and markets – and during the hours of daylight?

Last week's attack on the Sha'ab highway was carried out on a main road at midday during a sandstorm – when dozens of civilians are bound to be killed, whatever the pilot thought he was aiming at. "I had five sons and now I have only two – and how do I know that even they will survive?" a bespectacled middle-aged man said in the bare concrete back room of his home yesterday. "One of my boys was hit in the kidneys and heart. His chest was full of shrapnel; it came right through the windows. Now all I can say is that I am sad that I am alive." A neighbour interrupted to say that he saw the plane with his own eyes. "I saw the side of the aircraft and I noticed it changed course after it fired the missile."

Plane-spotting has become an all-embracing part of life in Baghdad. And to the reader who thoughtfully asked last week if I could see with my own eyes the American aircraft over the city, I have to say that in at least 65 raids by aircraft, I have not – despite my tiger-like eyes – actually seen one plane. I hear them, especially at night, but they are flying at supersonic speed; during the day, they are usually above the clouds of black smoke that wash over the city. I have, just once, spotted a cruise missile – the cruise or Tomahawk rockets fly at only around 400mph – and I saw it passing down a boulevard towards the Tigris river. But the grey smoke that shoots out of the city like the fingers of a dead hand is unmistakeable, along with the concussion of sound. And – when they can be found – the computer codings on the bomb fragments reveal their own story. As the codes on the Shu'ale missile surely must.

All morning yesterday, the Americans were at it again, blasting away at targets on the perimeter of Baghdad – where the outer defences of the city are being dug by Iraqi troops – and in the centre. An air-fired rocket exploded on the roof of the Iraqi Ministry of Information, destroying a clutch of satellite dishes. One office building from which I was watching the bombardment literally swayed for several seconds during one long raid. Even in the Al-Noor hospital, the walls were shaking yesterday as the survivors of the market slaughter struggled for survival.

Hussein Mnati is 52 and just stared at me – his face pitted with metal fragments – as bombs blasted the city. A 20-year-old man was sitting up in the next bed, the blood-soaked stump of his left arm plastered over with bandages. Only 12 hours ago, he had a left arm, a left hand, fingers. Now he blankly recorded his memories. "I was in the market and I didn't feel anything," he told me. "The rocket came and I was to the right of it and then an ambulance took me to hospital."

Whether or not his amputation was dulled by painkillers, he wanted to talk. When I asked him his name, he sat upright in bed and shouted at me: "My name is Saddam Hussein Jassem."


 FAIR USE NOTICE
This site contains material the use of which has not been authorized by the copyright owner. The material is made available in an effort to advance understanding of philosophical, political, and other issues. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in Section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml.

contact | report an error | forum | Frontline's "Long Road to War"

Materials in this section of the site for which original source documentation is specified are owned by their respective copyright holders. All the rest of the contents of this section is maintained by, and © 2003-2004, Brendan Lalor.

Terror Level
  Terror Alert Level

Login
 
 Username
 Password
 Remember me


Login Problems?


Newsletter
 
You are currently not logged in, but you can still subscribe to our newsletter.




New Web Links
  · Shields Up! Security site from Gibson Research Corp.
· Go2PDF Free PDF Print Driver
· Stellarium Night Sky (GPL free)
· TruthOut Media Page
· Global Rich List
· Google Earth
· Everest Home Edition
· American Institute of Philanthropy
· Skype - internet telephony
· If Americans Knew: Israeli-Palestinian Statistics

Off the Front Page
  · What is there It Is . org? (May 16, 2005)
· "A Moment of Silence" (Apr 06, 2005)
· Principles of Categorization (Apr 02, 2005)
· The Banality of Evil (Nov 13, 2004)
· Role of Letter Order in Parsing Language (Nov 05, 2004)
· How US trained butchers of Timor (Sep 15, 2004)
· A Note on the Morality of Fictional Wars: Fictum ad Bellum and Fictum in Bello (Sep 13, 2004)
· Can I Get a Job With a Philosophy Degree? (Aug 23, 2004)
· Well-Known Philosophy Majors (Aug 23, 2004)
· THE USES OF PHILOSOPHY (Aug 23, 2004)
· To Beat the Market: Hire a Philosopher (Aug 23, 2004)
· How to Get to the Top -- Study Philosophy (Aug 23, 2004)
· Philosophers Find the Degree Pays Off in Life And in Work (Aug 23, 2004)
· Alabama Gov. Bob Riley says his religious views influenced his push for a tax increase on the wealthy (Aug 18, 2004)
· Metaphor, Morality, and Politics, Or Why Conservatives Have Left Liberals In the Dust (Jul 02, 2004)
· Medicare and Manna from Heaven for Corporations (May 31, 2004)
· Global Population to Level Off? (May 27, 2004)
· Bush PR team covers China stamp with 'Made in U.S.A.' (May 21, 2004)
· Bush praises Sharon's pullout proposal (May 20, 2004)
· The Roots of Torture (May 19, 2004)
· Evangelicals Shape U.S. Foreign Policy (May 13, 2004)
· Brazil's Road to Victory Over U.S. Cotton (May 12, 2004)
· Those Who Deny the Crimes of the Past (May 11, 2004)
· Torture as Normalcy: As American as Apple Pie (May 09, 2004)
· U.S. Suspends Military Aid to Nearly 50 Countries (May 07, 2004)
· Kerry Won't Stop the War; But Independent Action Can (May 07, 2004)
· A carnival of unreason: The Anatomy of Fascism (May 03, 2004)
· Clinton Bombs Sudanese Pharmaceutical Plant (Apr 28, 2004)
· Curtains Ordered for Media Coverage of Returning Coffins (Apr 28, 2004)
· The Dystopic Duo: Sharon & Bush (Apr 27, 2004)

On this day in history ...
  1822
Brazil wins independence from Portugal.

1954
Integration of public schools begins in Washington, DC and Baltimore, MD.

1977
President Carter signs the Panama Canal Treaty ceding the canal to Panama.

1986
Desmond Tutu becomes the Archbishop of Capetown, South Africa, making him the first Black to head the Anglican Church in South Africa (two years earlier he had won the Nobel Peace Prize for his non-violent opposition to apartheid).



This website is developed and hosted by logoswebpublishing.com; its contents are maintained by, and ? 1999-2005, Brendan Lalor; however, comments posted on thereitis.org are the property of their posters. This site is created, maintained, and served using non-micro$oft products, including Apache, Linux, Perl, MySQL, and PostNuke, a web portal system (under the GNU/GPL license) written in PHP.