pertinent pointers  
 Welcome, Guest!  |  Login  |  Font Size: Large / Normal Monday, October 13, 2008 | 11:13 AM  
HOME  PHILOSOPHY SITE TOPICS IRAQ WAR WEB LINKS SEARCH
· About "Us"
· News Roundup
· Newsletters
· Peak Oil
· AvantGo
· News
· Reviews
· Videos
· Stats
· Recommend Us

Untitled Document
Support Us

Untitled Document
Quote

"You want us to be like good Germans, supporting the evils of our decade, and then when we refused to be good Germans and came to Chicago and demonstrated, now you want us to be like good Jews, going quietly and politely to the concentration camps while you and this court suppress freedom and the truth," Dellinger told the judge. "And the fact is, I am not prepared to do that."

-- David Dellinger, anti-war activist, 1969-1970

Untitled Document
Online
We have 6 guests and 0 members online

Welcome Guest, become a member today.

On the Illegitimacy of the Bush War on Iraq

Brendan Lalor | March, 2003; last updated July 31, 2003

 post to the forum on this topic 


The following document is from http://argument.independent.co.uk/low_res/story.jsp?story=390502&host=6&dir=140


Robert Fisk: The shocking truth about 'shock and awe'

The Independent - 25 March 2003

So far, the Anglo-American armies are handing their propaganda to the Iraqis on a plate. First, on Saturday, we were told – courtesy of the BBC – that Umm Qasr, the tiny Iraqi seaport on the Gulf, had "fallen". Why cities have to "fall" on the BBC is a mystery to me; the phrase comes from the Middle Ages when city walls literally collapsed under siege. Then we were told – again on the BBC – that Nasiriyah had been captured. Then its "embedded" correspondent informed us – and here my old journalistic suspicions were alerted – that it had been "secured".

Why the BBC should use the meretricious military expression "secured" is also a mystery to me. "Secured" is meant to sound like "captured" but almost invariably means that a city has been bypassed or half-surrounded or, at the most, that an invading army has merely entered its suburbs. And sure enough, within 24 hours, the Shia Muslim city west of the junction of the Euphrates and Tigress rivers proved to be very much unsecured, indeed had not been entered in any form – because at least 500 Iraqi troops, supported by tanks, were still fighting there.

With what joy did Taha Yassin Ramadan, the Iraqi Vice President, inform us all yesterday that "they claimed they had captured Umm Qasr but now you know this is a lie". With what happiness did Mohamed Said al-Sahaff, the Iraqi Information Minister, boast yesterday that Basra was still "in Iraqi hands", that "our forces" in Nasiriyah were still fighting.

And well could they boast because, despite all the claptrap put out by the Americans and British in Qatar, what the Iraqis said on this score was true. The usual Iraqi claims of downed US and British aircraft – four supposedly "shot down" around Baghdad and another near Mosul – were given credibility by the Iraqi ability to prove that the collapse of their forces in the south was untrue – quite apart from the film of prisoners obtained last night.

We know that the Americans are again using depleted uranium munitions in Iraq, just as they did in 1991. But yesterday, the BBC told us that US Marines had called up an A-10 strike aircraft to deal with "pockets of resistance" – a bit more military-speak from the BBC – but failed to mention that the A-10 uses depleted uranium rounds. So for the first time since 1991, we – the West – are spraying these uranium aerosols in battlefield explosions in southern Iraq; and we're not being told. Why not?

And where, for God's sake, does that wretched, utterly dishonest phrase "coalition forces" come from? There is no "coalition" in this Iraq war. There are the Americans and the British and a few Australians. That's it.

The "coalition" of the 1991 Gulf War does not exist. The "coalition" of nations willing to "help" with this illegitimate conflict includes, by a vast stretch of the imagination, even Costa Rica and Micronesia and, I suppose, poor old neutral Ireland, with its transit rights for US military aircraft at Shannon. But they are not "coalition forces". Why does the BBC use this phrase? Even in the Second World War, which so many journalists think they are now reporting, we didn't use this lie. When we landed on the coast of North Africa in Operation Torch, we called it an "Anglo-American landing".

And this is an Anglo-American war, whether we – and I include the "embedded ones" – like it or not. The Iraqis are sharp enough to remember all this. At first, they announced that captured US or British troops would be treated as mercenaries, a decision that Saddam himself wisely corrected yesterday when he stated that all prisoners would be treated "according to the Geneva Convention".

All in all, then, this has not been a great weekend for Messrs Bush and Blair. Nor, of course, for Saddam although he's been playing at wars for almost half the lifetime of Tony Blair. And even those journalists who have most bravely tried to see for themselves what is going on without the protection of their armies – an ITV crew near Nasiriyah, for example – are in mortal peril of their lives.

So here's a question from one who believed, only a week ago, that Baghdad might just collapse and that we might wake up one morning to find the Baathist militia and the Iraqi army gone and the Americans walking down Saadun Street with their rifles over their shoulders. If the Iraqis can still hold out against such overwhelming force in Umm Qasr for four days, if they can keep fighting in Basra and Nasiriyah – the latter a city that briefly rose in revolt against Saddam's regime in 1991 – why should Saddam's forces not keep fighting in Baghdad?

Certainly, Iraqi history will not be complete without a new story of "martyrdom" in the country's eternal battle against foreign occupiers. The last fighters of Um Qasr will become, in the years to come – whatever the fate of Saddam – men of song and legend. The Egyptians long ago did the same for their men killed at Suez in 1956.

Of course, this might all be a miscalculation. The pack of cards may be more flimsy that we think. But suddenly, this weekend, the quick and easy war, the conflict of "shock and awe" – the Pentagon's phrase is itself a classic slogan from the pages of the old Nazi magazine Signal – doesn't seem so realistic. Things are going wrong. We are not telling the truth. And the Iraqis are riding high on it all.


 FAIR USE NOTICE
This site contains material the use of which has not been authorized by the copyright owner. The material is made available in an effort to advance understanding of philosophical, political, and other issues. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in Section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml.

contact | report an error | forum | Frontline's "Long Road to War"

Materials in this section of the site for which original source documentation is specified are owned by their respective copyright holders. All the rest of the contents of this section is maintained by, and © 2003-2004, Brendan Lalor.

Terror Level
  Terror Alert Level

Login
 
 Username
 Password
 Remember me


Login Problems?


Newsletter
 
You are currently not logged in, but you can still subscribe to our newsletter.




New Web Links
  · Shields Up! Security site from Gibson Research Corp.
· Go2PDF Free PDF Print Driver
· Stellarium Night Sky (GPL free)
· TruthOut Media Page
· Global Rich List
· Google Earth
· Everest Home Edition
· American Institute of Philanthropy
· Skype - internet telephony
· If Americans Knew: Israeli-Palestinian Statistics

Off the Front Page
  · What is there It Is . org? (May 16, 2005)
· "A Moment of Silence" (Apr 06, 2005)
· Principles of Categorization (Apr 02, 2005)
· The Banality of Evil (Nov 13, 2004)
· Role of Letter Order in Parsing Language (Nov 05, 2004)
· How US trained butchers of Timor (Sep 15, 2004)
· A Note on the Morality of Fictional Wars: Fictum ad Bellum and Fictum in Bello (Sep 13, 2004)
· Can I Get a Job With a Philosophy Degree? (Aug 23, 2004)
· Well-Known Philosophy Majors (Aug 23, 2004)
· THE USES OF PHILOSOPHY (Aug 23, 2004)
· To Beat the Market: Hire a Philosopher (Aug 23, 2004)
· How to Get to the Top -- Study Philosophy (Aug 23, 2004)
· Philosophers Find the Degree Pays Off in Life And in Work (Aug 23, 2004)
· Alabama Gov. Bob Riley says his religious views influenced his push for a tax increase on the wealthy (Aug 18, 2004)
· Metaphor, Morality, and Politics, Or Why Conservatives Have Left Liberals In the Dust (Jul 02, 2004)
· Medicare and Manna from Heaven for Corporations (May 31, 2004)
· Global Population to Level Off? (May 27, 2004)
· Bush PR team covers China stamp with 'Made in U.S.A.' (May 21, 2004)
· Bush praises Sharon's pullout proposal (May 20, 2004)
· The Roots of Torture (May 19, 2004)
· Evangelicals Shape U.S. Foreign Policy (May 13, 2004)
· Brazil's Road to Victory Over U.S. Cotton (May 12, 2004)
· Those Who Deny the Crimes of the Past (May 11, 2004)
· Torture as Normalcy: As American as Apple Pie (May 09, 2004)
· U.S. Suspends Military Aid to Nearly 50 Countries (May 07, 2004)
· Kerry Won't Stop the War; But Independent Action Can (May 07, 2004)
· A carnival of unreason: The Anatomy of Fascism (May 03, 2004)
· Clinton Bombs Sudanese Pharmaceutical Plant (Apr 28, 2004)
· Curtains Ordered for Media Coverage of Returning Coffins (Apr 28, 2004)
· The Dystopic Duo: Sharon & Bush (Apr 27, 2004)

On this day in history ...
  1670
The Virginia Colony bans the enslavement of Blacks who arrive in the colony as baptized Christians; the ban is widely ignored and eventually repealed in 1682.

1943
Jews at Nazi death camp in Sobibor revolt; over 40 escape.

1970
Angela Davis arrested in N.Y.C. by FBI on false charges of aiding the escape of the Soledad Brothers.

1986
Police arrest 1,200 students occupying the University - Seoul, South Korea.

1987
Costa Rican president Oscar Arias is awarded the Nobel Peace Prize for ending the Central American conflicts fomented by the Reagan-Bush administration.

2001
An estimated 50,000 rally in London, 50,000 in Berlin, 25,000 in Stuttgart, and additional demonstrations take place in over 100 other cities in 19 countries to protest the US attack of Afghanistan.



This website is developed and hosted by logoswebpublishing.com; its contents are maintained by, and ? 1999-2005, Brendan Lalor; however, comments posted on thereitis.org are the property of their posters. This site is created, maintained, and served using non-micro$oft products, including Apache, Linux, Perl, MySQL, and PostNuke, a web portal system (under the GNU/GPL license) written in PHP.