Untitled Document
Untitled Document
 |
Quote |
| |
Charity is no substitute for justice witheld.
-- St. Augustine
|
Untitled Document
|
Online |
| |
We have 12 guests and 0 members online
Welcome Guest, become a member today.
|
|
|
|
|
The following document is from http://www.newsday.com/news/nationworld/iraq/ny-woclus0415.story
Grisly Results of U.S. Cluster Bombs
By Thomas Frank
Staff Correspondent
Newsday - April 15, 2003
The little boy wailed and moaned and squirmed on the hospital bed stained with his own blood. A doctor struggled to hold a gauze bandage over the boys' eyes, which no longer existed.
Ali Mustapha had found a small cylindrical object on the street near his Baghdad home Monday morning. He picked it up. He played with it. He had it in his hands and the object -- a live explosive -- literally blew up in his face.
At Kadhymia Hospital, Dr. Ausama Saadi's diagnosis was blunt: "He will be blind for the rest of his life. Ali is 4.
Although combat in Baghdad is virtually over, carnage continues as civilians are cut, gouged and killed when unexploded munitions in city neighborhoods suddenly detonate, often in the hands of people who don't know what they have innocently picked up. An alarming number of Iraqis being injured and killed are children, who are drawn to the small, grenade-like explosives that can look like toys, said doctors and parents.
"It doesn't look like a bomb, and they start to play with it, said Dr. Gelal Alta'ai at Kadhymia Hospital.
The suffering and reports of explosives detonating in Baghdad's neighborhoods have raised concerns among human rights groups that the United States fired scatter-shot rockets and artillery into heavily populated areas where their imprecise trajectories increase the possibility of civilian casualties.
"These are not the kind of weapons you use in cities, said Steve Goose, a weapons researcher for New York City-based Human Rights Watch.
The U.S. Central Command acknowledged Monday in response to questions from Newsday that U.S. forces have hit urban areas of Baghdad with "cluster bombs, which scatter hundreds of small "submunitions in an area the size of a football field.
A CentCom spokeswoman said that the cluster bombs were aimed at Iraqi missile systems and artillery and that "we had to use them in an urban environment because that was where Saddam Hussein put those weapons.
Human rights groups want cluster bombs banned because their hundreds of grenade-like explosives scatter widely, sometimes out of combat areas, and can linger for years, detonating unexpectedly.
"From a humanitarian perspective, you don't use them, because they're very hard to target, Goose said. He also noted that they have a high failure rate -- up to 25 percent -- leaving hundreds of bomblets "lying on the ground acting like little landmines.
In early April, the CentCom in Qatar began investigating reports that cluster bombs killed 11 civilians in Hillah, a city 60 miles south of Baghdad.
Goose said Monday's statement from CentCom was the first time he heard it confirmed that U.S. commanders had used cluster bombs in Baghdad.
Husain Hamed said one cluster bomb was fired into his Baghdad neighborhood. Four days ago, a group of children, including Hamed's son, Ali, 10, started playing with what Hamed said turned out to be a small explosive, about the size of a medicine bottle with a hollowed-out bottom.
Two children were killed when it exploded, Hamed said. His son's stomach was cut open, spilling out his intestines.
Ali lay in a bed at Kadhymia Hospital Monday. Bandages covered his entire stomach and both thighs, which were cut up by the blast. A tube was stuck in his abdomen to drain blood. Another tube in his nostrils feeds Ali, who cannot eat because his bowel is perforated.
"There must be some information about bombs so children know not to use it, Husain said. "Anyone can play with it. You can collect them. Suddenly, they will explode.
In another Baghdad neighborhood, Saef Sulaiman's younger brother carried an explosive into the house from outside Friday. Sulaiman, 17, was playing cards when it detonated, blasting shrapnel so deep into his buttocks that it hit bone.
At Raied Mahmod's stucco townhouse on a dusty residential street in northeastern Baghdad, an unexploded cylindrical munition roughly three inches long sat in the corner of his rooftop. Mahmod won't go near it.
Other explosives fired at his street six days ago gouged chunks of stucco out of the chest-high wall around the rooftop. The roof was punctured in five places by fist-sized holes surrounded by a splattering of small divots. U.S. soldiers have said a pattern of dents around a small hole indicates a cluster-bomb explosion.
Across the street, a sheet of paper taped to a home reads, "Don't enter the house because there are unexploded bombs.
Human rights groups question whether the firing of cluster bombs into densely populated areas violates international law. Advocates say such law prohibits militaries from using weapons indiscriminately.
Brig. Gen. Vincent Brooks, a CentCom spokesman, faced media questions Monday about why the United States would use such imprecise weapons as cluster bombs when officials have stressed precision attacks to avoid civilian casualties in a campaign to liberate Iraqi citizens. Brooks said cluster bombs can create "situational obstacles, such as blocking the movement of Iraqi soldiers.
"The conditions for people, the conditions for unintended consequences, are taken into account before the decision, Brooks said.
Dawwod Selman Alhamdany, who lives two doors from Mahmod, doesn't understand why three small explosives were fired through his roof one morning last week, incinerating three third-floor bedrooms but not hurting his family, who were on the first floor. Soot blackened the walls. Piles of charred remainslittered the floor. The acrid smell of fresh fire filled the air.
"It's only family. We don't have any soldiers here, Alhamdany said.
Some children hurt by explosives cannot get proper medical care because hospitals are operating without electricity -- which remains off throughout Baghdad -- or full staffing. Many hospital physicians are not going to work because they are afraid of unsafe conditions on the street or because they believe the hospitals are closed, doctors said.
Ali Mustapha, the boy who lost his eyes, could not get a CT scan Monday to help diagnose his deep skull wound because Kadhymia Hospital operates with just one power generator, which is not strong enough to run sophisticated machines, said Saadi, the doctor who treated him. The hospital's opthamology department is closed because opthamologists have not come to work.
So Mustapha received bare-bones treatment to stop his bleeding and keep him breathing.
"He will wait for specialized care, Saadi said. "I don't know how long. He'll be left just like this.
Staff correspondent Craig Gordon in Qatar contributed to this story.
| FAIR USE NOTICE | This site contains material the use of which has not been authorized by the copyright owner. The material is made available in an effort to advance understanding of philosophical, political, and other issues. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in Section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml.
|
contact | report an error | forum | Frontline's "Long Road to War"
Materials in this section of the site for which original source documentation is specified are owned by their respective copyright holders. All the rest of the contents of this section is maintained by, and © 2003-2004, Brendan Lalor.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Terror Level |
| |
 |
|
|
Login |
| |
|
|
|
Newsletter |
| |
You are currently not logged in, but you can still subscribe to our newsletter.
|
|
|
Off the Front Page |
| |
· What is there It Is . org?
(May 16, 2005)
· "A Moment of Silence"
(Apr 06, 2005)
· Principles of Categorization
(Apr 02, 2005)
· The Banality of Evil
(Nov 13, 2004)
· Role of Letter Order in Parsing Language
(Nov 05, 2004)
· How US trained butchers of Timor
(Sep 15, 2004)
· A Note on the Morality of Fictional Wars: Fictum ad Bellum and Fictum in Bello
(Sep 13, 2004)
· Can I Get a Job With a Philosophy Degree?
(Aug 23, 2004)
· Well-Known Philosophy Majors
(Aug 23, 2004)
· THE USES OF PHILOSOPHY
(Aug 23, 2004)
· To Beat the Market: Hire a Philosopher
(Aug 23, 2004)
· How to Get to the Top -- Study Philosophy
(Aug 23, 2004)
· Philosophers Find the Degree Pays Off in Life And in Work
(Aug 23, 2004)
· Alabama Gov. Bob Riley says his religious views influenced his push for a tax increase on the wealthy
(Aug 18, 2004)
· Metaphor, Morality, and Politics, Or Why Conservatives Have Left Liberals In the Dust
(Jul 02, 2004)
· Medicare and Manna from Heaven for Corporations
(May 31, 2004)
· Global Population to Level Off?
(May 27, 2004)
· Bush PR team covers China stamp with 'Made in U.S.A.'
(May 21, 2004)
· Bush praises Sharon's pullout proposal
(May 20, 2004)
· The Roots of Torture
(May 19, 2004)
· Evangelicals Shape U.S. Foreign Policy
(May 13, 2004)
· Brazil's Road to Victory Over U.S. Cotton
(May 12, 2004)
· Those Who Deny the Crimes of the Past
(May 11, 2004)
· Torture as Normalcy: As American as Apple Pie
(May 09, 2004)
· U.S. Suspends Military Aid to Nearly 50 Countries
(May 07, 2004)
· Kerry Won't Stop the War; But Independent Action Can
(May 07, 2004)
· A carnival of unreason: The Anatomy of Fascism
(May 03, 2004)
· Clinton Bombs Sudanese Pharmaceutical Plant
(Apr 28, 2004)
· Curtains Ordered for Media Coverage of Returning Coffins
(Apr 28, 2004)
· The Dystopic Duo: Sharon & Bush
(Apr 27, 2004)
|
|
|
On this day in history ... |
| |
1822
Brazil wins independence from Portugal.
1954
Integration of public schools begins in Washington, DC and Baltimore, MD.
1977
President Carter signs the Panama Canal Treaty ceding the canal to Panama.
1986
Desmond Tutu becomes the Archbishop of Capetown, South Africa, making him the first Black to head the Anglican Church in South Africa (two years earlier he had won the Nobel Peace Prize for his non-violent opposition to apartheid).
|
|
|
